Michael and Amber were fed up with their nagging neighbor, Margaret. But one day, they realized their kids had disappeared from the backyard. Thinking they may be at the neighbor’s house, they decided to investigate, but what they found chilled their bones.
In their quaint suburban home, Michael and Amber enjoyed the holiday cheer, surrounded by the home decorations they had just finished installing. As they reflected on celebrating their first Christmas with their adopted twins, Tom and Eliza, they were interrupted by their neighbor Margaret, an old woman who had opinions about everything.
“I understand Christmas is coming, but your decorations are shining right into my window,” Margaret griped.
Christmas Lights | Source: Shutterstock
“We just wanted our first Christmas with the kids to be special,” Michael said, smiling to keep the peace.
Amber joined in. “How about we turn them off at ten in the evening?”
Margaret crossed her arms. “That doesn’t suit me. I go to bed at nine,” she said.
Amber suggested, “Then, how about nine?”
“Fine,” she replied, twisting her mouth.
Amber and Michael looked at each other knowingly but stayed quiet. Their silent moment was broken by the twins, Tom and Eliza, drawn to the front door by the sound of their neighbor’s voice. Margaret’s demeanor softened at the sight of the children, something that made Michael’s hackles rise.
Gray-haired elderly woman | Source: Shutterstock
“My dears, I’ve brought you something,” she said, offering a plate of homemade cookies.
Frowning, Michael took the cookies before the twins could. “Knowing Margaret, there’s probably poison in there.”
The old woman sputtered and protested, “How dare you! I would never–”
Michael ended the encounter by wrangling his family into the house and closing the door in her face, thinking she was way too nasty to Amber and him and too nice to the children. It wasn’t normal.
The next day, Michael read a book while he listened to the twins playing outside. His eyes lifted for a second, and he noticed Margaret near the fence talking to them. His protective instincts stirred, but seeing no immediate harm, he chose not to intervene, focusing on his book again.
Children play outdoors | Source: Shutterstock
But soon enough, the atmosphere got too quiet. His head swiveled, and the realization hit: the twins were gone, and Margaret had disappeared, too.
“Tom! Eliza!” Michael called out, his voice rising with his panic. He rushed to the fence and saw Margaret’s car gone, too, and finally, he called out to Amber, who had been busy in their bedroom.
“Honey, the children are gone,” he said, breathing heavily once inside his house.
“What do you mean gone?” she asked, her eyes wide and fearful. “Maybe they’re hiding.”
“I think Margaret took them. She was talking to them, and now her car isn’t in her driveway anymore,” Michael said. “Call 911.”
“That’s too much–”
Collage of pictures with loved ones | Source: Shutterstock
“Call them, Amber!” he yelled but coughed when he saw her flinching. “Sorry. Please. I just have this feeling.”
***
“She’s 66, her name’s Margaret,” Michael explained to the police officers who arrived promptly.
One officer, trying to maintain focus, asked for details about Margaret while expressing doubt about the likelihood of her involvement due to her age. Then, he asked about cameras.
“No, we don’t have any cameras in the backyard. I never thought we’d need them,” he responded, running a hand through his hair.
“We’ll start a search immediately to gather as much information as quickly as possible,” the cop stated and walked off to talk to his partner. Soon, they took off, turning on their squad car lights to canvas the neighborhood.
Worried Woman | Source: Shutterstock
“I can’t wait anymore,” Michael said, marching toward Margaret’s house.
“What are you doing?” Amber followed, the panic clear in her voice.
Fortunately, they found the back door unlocked and walked right in, calling for her and their twins. But Michael stopped cold in the living room, causing Amber to run into his back. “What?” she asked before following his line of vision and experiencing the biggest chill of her life.
They discovered the walls covered with photographs of Tom and Eliza. The sheer number and nature of the photos were staggering. Some predated their adoption. “This… this is impossible,” Amber murmured, running a hand down her arm to calm her goosebumps.
Flashing lights of a police car | Source: Shutterstock
Michael grabbed his phone, taking pictures of the entire house in case they needed evidence. “Let’s get out of here,” he said, pulling his wife away from the dark, horrible place.
At home, they waited…and waited…and waited. No word from the police came. In the morning, Michael dialed CPS, asking for the social worker who had worked with them to adopt the kids, Darlene.
“What?” Darlene gasped when Michael finished telling her what happened. “What’s her full name?”
Michael repeated all the information he knew about their kidnapping neighbor and heard Darlene’s small “Oh, no” through the phone.
Stressed young man | Source: Shutterstock
Leave a Reply